California Plastic Bag Cleanup Figures Wrong, Says Researcher
gvw_gv_wire
By gvwire
Published 7 years ago on
January 22, 2018

Share


Opinion by
Steve Stein
In a recent post about California beach litter, GV Wire erroneously compared all littered items made from any type of plastic bag or film (e.g. garbage bags, ice bags, snack packaging bags, grocery/retail bags, Ziploc bags, dry cleaner bags and shrink wrap, etc.) littered in 2010 to just plastic grocery bags littered in 2017.
This claim is incorrect because in 2010 Ocean Conservancy aggregated these different plastic bag or film items into one catch-all category: Plastic Bags. Then, in 2013 Ocean Conservancy started breaking out Plastic Grocery Bags into a separate category, specifically separating them from all the other plastic bag-related items, the latter of which are now referred to as “Other Plastic Bags.”
The recorded number of Plastic Grocery Bags collected only seemed to drop dramatically in 2013 because Ocean Conservancy created two categories from one, thus reducing the number in each.

Most Recent Data

Using the most recent data provided by Ocean Conservancy, you will see that in 2016 Plastic Grocery Bags made up 1.7% of California litter (12,404 total items collected). In 2017, a little less than a year after SB 270 went into effect, Plastic Grocery Bags made up 1.5% of litter (11,847 total items collected). This represents a 0.2% decrease in Plastic Grocery Bags as a percentage of overall litter.
Your readers – and all Californians – deserve to know what the Ocean Conservancy data really shows: In almost a year since SB 270 was implemented (the only relevant timeframe to comment on the statewide bag ban’s impact), Plastic Grocery Bags have gone down only 0.2% as a percentage of all California beach litter.
I am an environmental scientist who researches litter. My firm has studied litter composition in California and throughout the U.S. In order to evaluate whether a policy like this is having an impact on reducing litter, it’s critical for organizations – including the news media – to report accurate information. In this case, the actual results a year into SB 270’s implementation are not particularly compelling at all.
About the Author
Steven Stein is principal of Environmental Resources Planning, LLC, based in the greater Washington, D.C., area.

DON'T MISS

23 for ’23: A Year in Photos

DON'T MISS

See How this Fresno roastery sends aid to Northern Thailand.

DON'T MISS

District Says Fresno Teachers Contract Proposal Would Bankrupt Budget Reserves by Year 3

DON'T MISS

Trump Vows to Ban Gaza Refugees, Expand Muslim Travel Ban If He Wins

DON'T MISS

The Supreme Court Orders Makers of Gun Parts to Comply with Rules on Ghost Guns

DON'T MISS

George W. Bush for Speaker? A Democratic Lawmaker Thinks It’s Possible

DON'T MISS

Former Navy IT Manager Gets Five Years for Hacking, ID Theft

DON'T MISS

Gunman Kills Two Swedes in Brussels, Prompting Terror Alert and Halt of Belgium-Sweden Soccer Match

DON'T MISS

Zakaria: The Best Response to Hamas Would Be to Keep the Saudi Deal Alive

DON'T MISS

Groundbreaking Human Brain Atlas Offers New Hope for Treating Neurological Disorders

UP NEXT

George W. Bush for Speaker? A Democratic Lawmaker Thinks It’s Possible

UP NEXT

What Does Destroying Gaza Solve?

UP NEXT

How Liberal California Compares to Florida, Texas on Social Media Regulation

UP NEXT

City of Fresno’s Israeli Flag Raising Draws Supporters and Protesters

UP NEXT

Former Fresno CC Coach Ed Madec Arrested for Allegedly Threatening to Kill Chancellor

UP NEXT

Trump Vows to Ban Gaza Refugees, Expand Muslim Travel Ban If He Wins

UP NEXT

Former Navy IT Manager Gets Five Years for Hacking, ID Theft

UP NEXT

Newsom Signs Law to Slowly Raise Healthcare Minimum Wage to $25

UP NEXT

Groundbreaking Human Brain Atlas Offers New Hope for Treating Neurological Disorders

UP NEXT

Oprah Winfrey Proposed 2020 Presidential Run with Mitt Romney, New Book Reveals

You May like

Trump Vows to Ban Gaza Refugees, Expand Muslim Travel Ban If He Wins

1 year ago

The Supreme Court Orders Makers of Gun Parts to Comply with Rules on Ghost Guns

1 year ago

George W. Bush for Speaker? A Democratic Lawmaker Thinks It’s Possible

1 year ago

Former Navy IT Manager Gets Five Years for Hacking, ID Theft

1 year ago

Gunman Kills Two Swedes in Brussels, Prompting Terror Alert and Halt of Belgium-Sweden Soccer Match

1 year ago

Zakaria: The Best Response to Hamas Would Be to Keep the Saudi Deal Alive

1 year ago

Groundbreaking Human Brain Atlas Offers New Hope for Treating Neurological Disorders

1 year ago

Newsom Signs Law to Slowly Raise Healthcare Minimum Wage to $25

1 year ago

Former Fresno CC Coach Ed Madec Arrested for Allegedly Threatening to Kill Chancellor

1 year ago

Jim Jordan’s Rapid Rise Cheered by Trump and Far Right. Could It Make Him Speaker?

1 year ago

HOT OFF THE PRESS

23 for ’23: A Year in Photos

1 year ago

1 year ago

Trump Vows to Ban Gaza Refugees, Expand Muslim Travel Ban If He Wins

1 year ago

The Supreme Court Orders Makers of Gun Parts to Comply with Rules on Ghost Guns

Photo of a hacker typing on a laptop

1 year ago

Former Navy IT Manager Gets Five Years for Hacking, ID Theft

1 year ago

Gunman Kills Two Swedes in Brussels, Prompting Terror Alert and Halt of Belgium-Sweden Soccer Match